A painful back tooth does not automatically mean you need a dental implant. Root canal treatment works on the tooth you still have; an implant replaces a missing tooth. If you are weighing up keeping the tooth or having it removed and replaced, start with an assessment rather than choosing a replacement first. healthdirect explains root canal treatment and the separate dental implant procedure.
At The Dental Co. in Windsor, our root canal treatment information describes examining the tooth and taking X-rays before planning care. Our implant consultation also starts with assessment. The question to bring is: can this back tooth be treated and restored, and what would each option involve for me?

What is the difference between saving a tooth and replacing it?
Root canal treatment removes damaged or infected pulp, the soft tissue inside the tooth. The canals are cleaned and filled, and the tooth is then restored with a filling or crown. The aim is to keep the natural tooth. An implant is a metal post placed in the jaw where a missing tooth’s roots were, with an artificial tooth attached above it.
These are different treatment pathways, not two fillings to choose between. If the tooth is badly damaged or infected, extraction is an alternative to root canal treatment. If it is removed, discuss whether and how to replace it. healthdirect lists a bridge and removable dentures as alternatives to an implant; ask which options apply to your mouth.
Which signs mean a back tooth needs checking?
Pain when biting or chewing, sensitivity to hot or cold, spontaneous toothache and swelling near the tooth can occur with pulp damage or disease. A root canal infection can also cause a darker tooth or a pimple-like bump on the gum. These are reasons to see a dentist, not a way to decide for yourself that the tooth needs removal.
Some pulp problems have no obvious symptoms. Better Health Channel’s root canal guidance explains that tests or X-rays may identify them during dental care. Neither the amount of pain nor the absence of pain can replace an examination when deciding what to do with the tooth.
If you have severe pain or swelling, make an urgent dental appointment. If you think you have a tooth abscess, see a dentist or doctor urgently rather than waiting for a routine implant consultation. healthdirect’s tooth abscess advice explains that an abscess will not get better on its own and can spread.
How does the dentist work out whether the tooth can be kept?
The dentist asks about your symptoms, examines the tooth and uses investigations such as X-rays. Better Health Channel explains that the images also show the roots and help plan root canal treatment. Previous decay or cracks may have removed substantial tooth structure, so restoring the tooth afterwards is part of the discussion, not an optional detail to leave until later.
Ask the dentist to explain what the examination shows about this tooth, which treatment is being proposed and what its limitations are. Root canal treatment may help retain a damaged or infected tooth, but it is not always enough to manage a significant infection; extraction may still be needed. The reason for recommending either pathway should be discussed for your situation.
- What has caused the problem in this tooth?
- Can the tooth be treated and restored, and what remains uncertain?
- Would the plan include a filling or crown after root canal treatment?
- If removal is recommended, what are the replacement choices?
- Which step needs attention now, and which decisions can be discussed at a later visit?
Would a root canal on a molar take several visits?
It may. Back teeth can have several roots and canal spaces, and the difficulty of treatment affects the number of visits. healthdirect says root canal treatment usually needs a few appointments; our clinic’s service information also explains that additional sessions may be needed. Ask for a plan for your tooth rather than assuming everything will be finished in one visit.
Treatment includes numbing the area with local anaesthetic, removing the affected pulp and cleaning and shaping the canals. A temporary filling may be placed between sessions. After the canals are filled and sealed, the tooth needs its final restoration. Ask which visits cover the canal treatment and which cover the filling or crown.
Some discomfort can occur after treatment. Ask your dentist which pain relief is suitable, what you can eat and when to resume your usual activities. Our root canal page advises contacting the dentist about severe pain, swelling or other concerning symptoms after treatment. Follow your own aftercare instructions and attend the planned follow-up.
Would an implant mean fewer appointments?
Do not assume so. healthdirect’s implant information describes treatment in stages over a few months, including imaging, placement in the jaw, healing and attachment of the artificial tooth. Before recommending an implant, the dental professional checks the available bone, gums, medical conditions and medicines.
The Dental Co.’s implant page separates assessment, any preparatory procedures, placement, healing, restoration and follow-up. Some patients need bone grafting or a sinus lift. Ask which stages are relevant to you and whether they are included in the proposed timeline and quotation; a website outline is not your personal treatment schedule.
For background on replacement treatment, read what dental implants are and how they work. If you already have a proposed plan, our article about asking for a second opinion offers questions for a further assessment. Neither article can decide whether your existing tooth should be removed.
What risks and limitations should we discuss?
Root canal treatment can involve recurrent infection, injury to the root, discolouration or a small instrument becoming stuck in a canal. Further treatment may be required, and some teeth still need removal. Your dentist should explain which concerns matter for the tooth being assessed.
Implant placement is surgery. Possible complications include infection, nerve damage, sinus problems and damage to nearby teeth; pain, bruising, swelling and bleeding may occur afterwards. Our implant page also explains that an implant may fail to join with the bone and need removal. Choosing replacement treatment does not remove treatment risks.
There is no single option that this article can recommend for every painful back tooth. Ask about the risks and limitations of keeping the tooth, removing it and any proposed replacement. If you delay treatment for an infected tooth, the infection can worsen and the tooth may need removal; discuss timing with the dentist rather than waiting for pain to settle.
How do I compare the plans and costs?
Ask for the whole proposed pathway, not just the price of one stage. healthdirect advises discussing root canal costs with the dentist and knowing all implant costs before starting treatment. Our clinic describes a personalised implant plan covering procedures, timeline and associated costs.
- Does the root canal estimate include all sessions and the final filling or crown?
- If the tooth is removed, which removal and replacement steps are included?
- Are additional assessments or preparatory procedures quoted separately?
- What follow-up is planned, and what happens if further treatment is needed?
- Which item details can I take to my health fund to ask about my own benefits?
What should I tell The Dental Co. when I call?
Start with the problem: where the pain is, whether there is swelling and whether another dentist has recommended root canal treatment or extraction. Say if treatment has already started. Ask which assessment to book and what it will cost; do not book on the assumption that a particular procedure can be done that day.
Our new-patient information asks you to bring previous dental records or X-rays, your medication list and health-fund details if you have them. For a painful tooth, ask reception which appointment is appropriate rather than assuming the standard new-patient visit is the right one.
Call (03) 9908 8100 or use our contact page to enquire. The Dental Co. is at Level 2, 6–10 Chapel Street, Windsor. You can read about Dr. Justtin Daniels, Principal Dentist, the author of this article, on his clinic profile.
Sources and general information
Sources checked 9 November 2026. This is general patient education, not a diagnosis or a recommendation to have a tooth removed, undergo root canal treatment or choose an implant. Your dentist needs to assess your tooth and explain your own options, risks and timing.
- healthdirect: Root canal treatment, reviewed February 2025
- Victorian Department of Health, Better Health Channel: Root canal treatment, reviewed July 2025
- healthdirect: Tooth abscess, reviewed June 2025
- healthdirect: Dental implant procedure, reviewed February 2025
- The Dental Co.: Root canal treatment
- The Dental Co.: Dental implants
- The Dental Co.: New Patient Expectations